Why do I keep attracting the wrong people?
Casen Psychology | Sara Casen, PhD
Sometimes people repeatedly find themselves in relationships with incompatible partners due to ingrained patterns subconsciously guiding who they notice, pursue, and tolerate. Clients often ask some version of Why do I keep attracting the wrong people, and the question is worth exploring seriously.
What might be happening…
The dynamic is often more about what feels familiar than what is actually healthy for you.
Some people notice they are drawn to partners who are hard to reach, inconsistent, or emotionally unavailable. Others find that steadier, kinder people feel oddly flat by comparison. This can be disorienting, especially when you genuinely want something different.
Research on adult relationships suggests that early experiences can shape what closeness feels like to us. A closer look at how attachment styles shape adult relationships helps explain why certain partners feel magnetic even when they are a poor match.
Common misconceptions worth clearing up
One frequent belief is that this pattern means something is fundamentally wrong with you. A repeating dynamic is information, not a verdict. It often points to a specific set of expectations and responses that need to be examined. Another misconception is that the answer is simply to try harder or pick better on paper. Many clients have already made thoughtful choices and still felt the same dynamic resurface. The “pull” sometimes supersedes the conscious decision-making, which is part of why it feels so hard to change.
It also helps to separate two experiences people sometimes blur together. For some, the pull toward unavailable partners is tangled up with dating anxiety that makes safer connections feel unfamiliar or even boring. Naming which pattern is at work may impact an individual’s next step.
The flip side people miss
Not everyone chases the wrong partners. Some people find themselves quietly withdrawing the moment things get real. The flip side of chasing the wrong people is often pushing people away once they get close, and both patterns can stem from the same underlying fears.
You might recognize yourself in one, or move between both depending on the relationship. Either way, the recurring theme usually says more about a protective pattern than about the specific people involved.
When support may help
You do not need to experience a crisis in order to look at this more closely. Some people reach out after a particular relationship ends. Others notice the same story repeating and want to understand it before starting something new. Support can be worth considering when the pattern feels automatic, when it interferes with the kind of connection you want, or when you find yourself explaining away behavior that troubles you. Therapy can offer a structured place to examine the pattern you find yourself repeating.
Dr. Sara Casen offers therapy focused on young adults, providing sessions in West LA and via telehealth to California and New York.
What working on this can look like
Working through recurring patterns is a core focus of relationships and dating therapy, where the goal is to understand why the same dynamics keep resurfacing. Sessions aim to help you understand recurring patterns through goal-directed and collaborative work. Early on, treatment planning includes reflecting on what you want to gain in therapy and where you might hope to be in the future. Dr. Casen’s sessions draw on Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, psychodynamic therapy, and attachment-based approaches. Sessions often include specific tools and homework so the work continues between appointments.
A gentle next step
If any of this resonates, an initial conversation can be a good starting point. Dr. Casen offers a complimentary phone consultation to discuss what you are looking for, answer your questions, and consider whether the two of you are a good fit. Scheduling and payment are reviewed during that same call.
FAQ
-
Knowing something intellectually and feeling it are often two different systems. Many clients understand a relationship is not serving them and still feel a strong pull toward it. That gap tends to reflect familiar emotional patterns rather than poor judgment. Therapy can help examine what the pull is responding to, which sometimes loosens its grip over time.
-
Patterns that feel automatic are often responding to expectations formed over time; those expectations can be carefully explored and potentially revised. Clients sometimes may begin noticing small shifts in how they interpret their own reactions within the first few sessions. Change usually reflects consistent, introspective work rather than a single insight.
Finding the right support is a journey.
If any of this resonated, a consultation call is a low-pressure way to continue to explore if my approach feels like the right fit for you.